St. John's can't complete another comeback as 10-game win streak snapped by Villanova

The Red Storm could not finish another impressive road comeback victory

Feb 12, 2025; Villanova, Pennsylvania, USA; Villanova Wildcats guard Tyler Perkins (4) celebrates with forward Enoch Boakye (13) and guard Jordan Longino (15) after the game against St. John's basketball at William B. Finneran Pavilion.
Feb 12, 2025; Villanova, Pennsylvania, USA; Villanova Wildcats guard Tyler Perkins (4) celebrates with forward Enoch Boakye (13) and guard Jordan Longino (15) after the game against St. John's basketball at William B. Finneran Pavilion. | Kyle Ross-Imagn Images

The St. John’s basketball team had to do what it has proven to be best at on Wednesday night – rally from a double-digit deficit on the road and it looked like the No. 9 Johnnies were up for the challenge again.

After Villanova took its largest lead of the game, 59-48 with 9:56 remaining, the Red Storm ripped off a 14-0 run in just 3:24 to lead by three, 62-59, but it couldn’t deliver a knockout punch.

The Wildcats went on a 9-2 run, sparked by a pair of 3-pointers from Eric Dixon that gave ‘Nova a four-point lead, 68-64, but St. John’s wasn’t done. Simeon Wilcher put the Red Storm ahead, 71-70, with a 3-pointer with 27.9 left but Tyler Perkins, who finished 4-of-5 from 3-point range, responded with a triple of his own to but the Wildcats back in front with 9.0 seconds remaining.

St. John’s, after a timing review, went back to Wilcher to try and win the game but his 3-pointer was off target and the Red Storm had its 10-game winning streak snapped, losing 73-71.

“I knew it was off,” Wilcher said of the final attempt. “It was a clean look, I just didn’t make it.”

After making his first three shot attempts, Wilcher finished with 12 points on 4-of-11 shooting, including 3-of-9 from distance.

“Twice we didn’t block out and it cost us the game,” Rick Pitino said.

He was referring to Dixon’s 3-pointer off an offensive rebound that gave Villanova (15-10, 8-6 Big East) a 65-62 lead and another offensive rebound that led to free throw from Jordan Longino to push the Wildcat lead to four, 70-66.

“That’s been a weakness of ours and it finally bit us in the [backside].”

Villanova only had seven offensive rebounds in its victory that led to nine points but really flexed its muscles in the paint outscoring the Red Storm 24-16.

St. John’s (21-4, 12-2 Big East) relied heavily on the 3-point ball, shooting a season-high 37 attempts and making just 11 while the Wildcats connected on 11-of-24. Aaron Scott led the Red Storm with 22 points on 5-of-13 from beyond the arc.

“That wasn’t the reason we lost,” Pitino said of his team’s 3-point shooting. “People are going to give [3-point shots] to us, we have to have the confidence to take it.”

St. John’s trailed by as many as 10 points in the first half, 32-22, but went into the halftime locker room on a 10-2 run in the final 3:49 while holding Villanova to just two points in the final 5:46.

The Red Storm opened the second half by scoring the first five points, taking a 37-34 lead, before Villanova began to pull away.

St. John’s was without key guard Deivon Smith, who suffered a neck injury in practice on Sunday.

The Johnnies return home on Sunday afternoon (3:00 p.m. ET, FS1) when hosting No. 24 Creighton (18-7, 11-3 Big East) at Madison Square Garden with the winner taking control of first place in the Big East regular season standings.